By J.E.
When I first started studying Japanese, I tried to use traditional textbooks. But since I was working on my own without the benefit of an instructor, I didn’t get very far. Some of the grammar was very difficult to understand, and since I didn’t have anyone to ask questions of, I gave up pretty quickly.
Then I heard about the so-called Pimsleur method, and decided to give the audio program a try. Fortunately, I knew someone who already had the CDs, so I didn’t have to spend $300 of my own.
The Pimsleur Japanese program relies entirely on audio input, repetition, and anticipation in order to help students learn the language. You start out by listening to basic conversations between a native Japanese speaker and a foreigner who doesn’t know much Japanese at all. Then, you have to repeat the sentences you hear — bit by bit at first — until you can say the whole thing by yourself. Along the way, different vocabulary words are introduced, but their meanings are just briefly explained. Grammar, too, is given just the most basic explanations possible.
There are 20 lessons in this Japanese 1 program, and each one lasts approximately 30 minutes. Students are encouraged to go back and repeat lessons as necessary until they achieve an 80% comprehension rate.
I found the Pimsleur audio lessons to be somewhat helpful, but can’t imagine ever becoming even close to fluent by relying on this method alone. First of all, there’s not nearly enough vocabulary given throughout the 20 lessons. Instead, the lessons just employ the same vocab: beer, sake, restaurant, lunch, dinner, etc. It doesn’t take much effort to remember those words, so I don’t see why lots of new words shouldn’t have been included.
Additionally, I felt the lessons themselves were pretty boring since you’re basically repeating the same two or three conversations for 30 minutes. I would have liked a bit more variety in that respect, but understand that the whole basis of the Pimsleur method is this very type of repetition.
Overall, I think the Pimsleur Japanese I series could help you learn enough Japanese to make your way as a tourist, but you certainly won’t be able to have substantial conversations after this course alone. In that regard, I don’t think this title is worth the $300 list price. If you can borrow it, I say go for it. But don’t waste your own money on the series.