E.B. White’s children’s classic Charlotte’s Web was one of my favorite books when I was a kid. I must have read it at least 50 times back then, and the story never lost its magic. I also saw the 1973 animated feature a few times, and remember liking that as well. Of course now it’s been at least 20 years since I’ve taken in Charlotte’s Web in any form, so I was basically going into the 2006 film with no real expectations as to what I might get out of this latest version.
Charlotte’s Web presents viewers with a combination of live action and CGI, so there’s a somewhat more realistic feel to what takes place in the Zuckerman’s barnyard in Maine. The basic story, in case you’ve forgotten, is as follows: a sow gives birth to a litter of pigs on the Arable farm early one morning. Young Fern Arable (played by Dakota Fanning) rushes out to the barn in excitement to see the new arrivals, but she unexpectedly walks in on her father grabbing an axe and the runt of the litter. There’s no sense in keeping the runt around, he says, because it will just die off anyway (in a survival of the fittest sense). Fern refuses to let her father kill the runt, promising to take care of it and raise it herself. Mr. Arable reluctantly agrees.
Fern names the pig Wilbur and spends a lot of time with him. She feeds him from a bottle, plays with him, bathes him in the sink, and even brings him to school. Unfortunately, he’s growing fast and Mr. Arable insists that now is the time for Fern to get rid of the pig once and for all. Fern takes Wilbur across the road to her uncle Homer’s farm and promises to continue to visit Wilbur every day.
Once Wilbur is in the barnyard, we realize that he and the other animals can actually talk. Wilbur (voiced by Dominic Scott Kay) starts asking the other animals (which consist of some cows, sheep, geese, a horse, and a rat) to chat with him and be his friend, but they pretty much ignore him.
Then one night Wilbur hears a voice from someone who says she’ll be his friend. That voice belongs to Charlotte (Julia Roberts), a spider that lives above the barnyard door. Wilbur happily agrees to this, but the other animals all laugh at the arrangement. Why would Wilbur want to be friends with a lowly spider?
But Wilbur doesn’t see it that way. He’s willing to be friendly to everyone, including Templeton the Rat (Steve Buscemi), whom none of the other animals seem to want anything to do with.
Anyway, Charlotte and Wilbur become friends, and Charlotte devises a way to help save Wilbur from becoming Christmas dinner. She starts spinning descriptive words into her web in an attempt to make Wilbur famous because then Farmer Zuckerman wouldn’t want to slaughter him. She writes things like, “Some pig”, “Terrific”, “Radiant”, and “Humble”, and these words do indeed save Wilbur. He ends up winning an award and living a long, happy life in the barn. Those of you already familiar with the story know what happened to Charlotte; those of you not familiar with the story will have to see the film to find out.
My Reaction: I thought this version of Charlotte’s Web was very watchable and, for the most part, rather entertaining. Nothing could compare to E.B. White’s original book, however, so it wouldn’t really be fair to hold the film up to that lofty standard.
Strengths:
- The movie was nice and short, and was able to hold my 4-year–old son’s interest for long stretches.
- The only really slow parts (judging by my son’s actions) were the scenes showing Fern and her new boyfriend at the fair and other scenes in which the animals didn’t appear at all.
- The CGI was reasonably good and as a result, none of the animals were particularly distracting.
- The gist of the story and much of the emotion came through in this version, even if the re-telling wasn’t very inspired.
Weaknesses:
- I didn’t like Julia Roberts as the voice of Charlotte. The voice was very flat and came off as quite preachy and superior, and I was a bit put off by this.
- As an adult it was difficult at times to get into the story. There were occasions when I would look at the screen and see a pig talking to a spider rather than Wilbur talking to Charlotte, and that of course made things seem rather ridiculous. When reading the book, it’s easy to forget that the story is about animals; not so on film.
Overall, I give this adaptation of Charlotte’s Web 7.0 stars out of 10. I think it offers something for both kids and adults, and should definitely be a candidate for your next family movie night.
It feels like I haven’t been reading very much recently, so I decided to make a push in the last couple of days in order to finish up Agatha Christie’s Murder in Mesopotamia. This novel was published in 1936 and once again features Hercule Poirot as the lead detective. Here’s what happened in the book.