I inevitably start feeling a bit guilty whenever I stray from classic literature for too long. I have spent the better part of the last year reading Agatha Christie, Nicholas Sparks, and Anita Shreve while listening to Michael Connelly audiobooks, so it’s no wonder that I just had to put those authors aside for a couple of weeks in order to knock out another title from the Observer’s list of the 100 greatest novels of all time. I’ve had The Black Sheep by HonorĂ© de Balzac sitting on my shelf for several months now, so it was high time I read it. Here’s what I thought of the No.12 book on the list.
Plot summary (with possible spoilers): The Black Sheep tells the story of two brothers who are polar opposites of each other. On the one hand, we have Phillipe Bridau, a dashing soldier who was an aide-de-camp of Napoleon’s before the Emperor was banished into exile. When Phillipe refused to swear allegiance to the new rulers, he was left to a life of idleness and dissipation. He lost his commission, had no money, and spent every night gambling and drinking until he passed out. He financed his debauchery by stealing from family members and friends.
On the other hand, we have Joseph, an up-and-coming artist who is every bit as ugly as Phillipe is handsome. Joseph has all the sense and work ethic that Phillipe lacks, and he is the one who ensures that their widowed mother Agathe has a roof over her head and food to eat.
Despite all of Phillipes shortcomings and transgressions, he remains the apple of Agathe’s eye. She makes excuses for him, even when he goes so far as to cause the death of her aunt. Then, when Phillipe is arrested for taking part in a conspiracy against the crown, Agathe does her utmost to raise money for his freedom. This entails traveling to a town called Issoudun to try to convince her estranged brother Jean-Jacques Rouget to give her a fair share of the vast inheritance she was cheated out of years ago.
Joseph and Agathe soon see that Rouget is completely under the thumb of a woman named Flore who has been his live-in lover for more than a decade. It’s clear that Flore is just after the old man’s money, but Rouget is so head over heels for her that he gives in to her every demand — even when it comes to letting her real lover, Maxence Gilet, move into the house as well.
Joseph and Agathe are basically run out of town by Maxence and his band of troublemakers. They don’t get their hands on any of the money, but it turns out that Maxence’s problems are just beginning. That’s because Phillipe gets released from prison and is assigned to serve probation in Issoudun. Phillipe then sets his mind on outsmarting both Max and Flore in order to get the money for himself.
Phillipe actually succeeds in his attempts, and in a few years finds himself the master of the entire Rouget fortune. But he is such a cold-hearted monster that he doesn’t give his mother or brother a sou, even when Agathe appeals directly to him for help because they are starving and in debt.
Phillipe gets his just desserts in the end, however, as he’s beheaded on the battlefield. Having left no heir or wife behind, Joseph ends up with the remaining fortune.
My Reaction: I thought the early part of the novel (actually, the first two-thirds) was a bit dry and boring, particularly when Balzac took his sweet time in providing lengthy background information regarding the Rouget fortune and the town of Issoudun. It took me forever to get through those two parts, and while I completely understand the need to supply this type of backstory, I just wish Balzac had done so more concisely.
But fortunately Joseph, Phillipe, Agathe, and Maxence were such richly drawn characters that I was able to push on and make it to the most interesting part of the novel, which was when Phillipe arrived at Issoudun. The way he and Maxence sized each other up and engaged in their cat-and-mouse game was masterfully presented, and made for compelling reading.
I loved the way Agathe found it in her heart to admit to Joseph that she should have loved him more, but only wish she had a chance to renounce Phillipe to his face before she died. I can’t believe what a heartless son and brother he was, and throughout the entire novel, I kept thinking to myself, “My god, I hope my boy doesn’t turn out this way!”
Overall, I found The Black Sheep to be an excellent novel. I liked it much more than I thought I would, and definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a good read. I don’t know that I’d go so far as to call it the 12th-best book ever written, but what do I know! I give it 7.5 stars out of 10.

I mentioned last week when I wrote my recap of Burn Notice 1×10 that I somehow completely skipped over 1×09. Luckily, my TiVo was programmed to record it as usual, so I was able to catch up over the weekend. I was kinda disappointed that I didn’t learn anything new from this episode, which was called Hard Bargain. That just means the ep was filler and that it wasn’t even necessary to watch it at all.