By J.E.
As much as I enjoy watching movies with my five-year-old son, I nevertheless get tired of the endless parade of Disney-like animated films that dominate the children’s genre these days. Whatever happened to good, old-fashioned live action movies suitable for the entire family? Does anyone even make these types of movies anymore?
In looking through the Children’s section at Blockbuster, I would have to say no, as an overwhelming majority of the new stuff is animated or CGI. One of the only live action choices available to us last weekend was Shiloh 2: Shiloh Season from way back in 1999. I would have gone for the original Shiloh, but it was out (perhaps some other parents were feeling the same way I did), so we had to settle for the sequel. Fortunately, enjoying the second film didn’t really depend much on seeing the first.
Plot summary (with possible spoilers): Shiloh 2 takes place in a small, rural community and focuses on the life of pre-adolescent Marty Preston (played by Zachary Browne) and his dog Shiloh. Marty had rescued Shiloh from his original abusive owner, local drunk and all-around meanie Judd Travers (Scott Wilson) by doing odd jobs for Judd, and now Marty and Shiloh are inseparable.
It’s too bad that Judd seemingly has nothing better to do than harass Marty and the rest of the Preston clan, including father Ray (Michael Moriarty) and mother Louise (Ann Dowd) by illegally hunting on their land, drinking and driving, and generally making a nuisance of himself to the point that the Prestons are afraid to let their young daughters play freely on their own property. Oh, and Judd also has a habit of eyeing Shiloh in a way that makes it clear he wants the dog back.
The plot progresses leisurely through a series of scenes designed to show where everyone stands in relation to each other before a crisis — Judd getting into a near-fatal accident — pushes the characters to address the issues plaguing their lives.
My Reaction: As far as movies go, Shiloh 2: Shiloh Season is about as simplistic as they come — which is a good thing in this case, since it’s for children. Not a lot happens in it, so it’s very easy for even young kids with short attention spans to follow the plot. Sure, the scenes feel completely disjointed and somewhat random to adults, but I’m willing to overlook that because of the fact that my son actually enjoyed watching the film.
Personally, I felt that it took far too long for the “crisis” to develop. I would have preferred to see Judd’s accident happen a bit earlier so we could get a few extra scenes about how Marty and Judd’s relationship changed after they became friends. For young kids, I think a few visual reinforcements of this newly forged friendship would have been helpful.
As it was, viewers have to settle for a voiceover telling us that Judd thinks Marty is “alright by him” — a line that went right past my son. After building Judd up to be such a bad guy, it would have been nice for younger kids to see him being nicer instead of just hearing about it. Yes, there was the whole scene where Judd invited Marty and Ray into his shack and offered them potato chips, but I have a feeling that was a bit too subtle for younger viewers.
Overall, Shiloh 2: Shiloh Season is a decent family film. Younger kids will enjoy the parts that show Marty bonding with his dog, but might not understand the implications of Marty being nice to Judd later on. Older children will be able to explore deeper thematic issues, such as what makes people mean in the first place and why you should never give up on a mean person, just keep treating them with kindness. I give this movie 5.5 stars out of 10.