John C. Reilly is one of those guys who always seems to be cast in a supporting role. He played second fiddle to Will Ferrell in Talladega Nights, to Mark Wahlberg in Boogie Nights, to Richard Gere in Chicago, and has had bit roles in lots of other projects.
So how would he do as the lead? Did he have enough of a screen presence to carry an entire film on his own? Reilly sought to answer that question in 2007′s Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story, a send-up of all the musician biopics that have hit the market in recent years, with the most obvious ones being Walk the Line and Ray.
Plot summary (with possible spoilers): The film opens with Dewey Cox (Reilly) about to take the stage for one final performance before accepting a lifetime achievement award. Before going out there, however, he takes a moment to reflect on his experiences up to that point, which sends us into flashback mode starting with his childhood in Alabama.
As a boy, Dewey spent lots of time with older brother Nate (played by Chip Hormess), a virtuoso on the piano who was surely destined for great things. One day as the boys were playing with machetes in the barn, Dewey accidentally cuts Nate in half, killing him. This traumatic event caused a rift between Dewey and his father (Raymond J. Barry), who from that point forward would proclaim that “the wrong kid died” every chance he got. But it also got Dewey started on his own path to music, as he started playing the guitar and exhibited some skills with that instrument.
A few years later, Dewey plays at his high school talent show, and wows the crowd with his songs. He hooks up with Edith (Kristen Wiig), whom he soon marries, and leaves Alabama to try to become a star.
The rest of the film then follows Dewey’s career, as he rises to the top of the music world, sinks down to rock bottom under the weight of personal and drug problems, and makes another comeback before dying on stage. As this movie was intended to be a spoof of similar biopics, there are lots of scenes that mimic stuff from Walk the Line (ripping the sink out of the wall, for instance) or Ray (a band mate saying “you don’t want to get involved in this” — meaning drugs). Someone more familiar with those other films could probably pick out more parallels, but those are the ones that immediately come to mind.
My Reaction: I thought Walk Hard was an average film. I laughed out loud several times during the course of the movie, but felt that some of the running gags were just dumb. For instance, the whole thing about cutting his brother in half might have been ok if the screenwriters didn’t keep bringing it up every 10 minutes. Of course, I thought it was incredibly dumb that the brother kept right on talking after he was chopped in half, but I guess I can see how some people might find that funny.
My favorite parts of the movie were all of the “You don’t want any part of this” drug scenes, especially when the Tim Meadows character was talking about marijuana and couldn’t really find anything negative to say about it. That running gag worked fairly well, but the other one did not.
This film did a great job of showing how the lives of so many famous musicians are eerily similar. They rise from humble beginnings; put out a hit song; get into drugs, alcohol, and women; spiral out of control; hit bottom; and then climb back up to the top. Hell, I bet I could write a biopic screenplay of my own with this template, and then just insert a current star’s name in there. In fact, we’re watching it unfold in real time with Britney Spears right now. How long will it be before her biopic is released?
Would Walk Hard have been a better or more successful picture with a bigger star than John C. Reilly in the lead? It’s impossible to say for sure. I thought he was decent in this role, but not great, and I’ve never found the actor to be particularly charismatic in any performance I’ve seen him in. In other words, he gets the job done, but doesn’t bring anything extra to the table.
Overall, Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story was a decent comedy with some funny parts and many jokes that simply fell flat. I give it 3 stars out of 5.