Most of the time, I don’t even think twice about watching a movie that’s based on a novel because screenwriters generally do a decent job of capturing the gist of the story in their scripts. Yes, I know that it’s exceedingly difficult to get an adaptation “just right”, and that people will forever quibble about what the screenwriter chose to include or leave out, but for the most part, you don’t have to be familiar with the book in order to enjoy the film.
However, I think the opposite may be true for The Golden Compass. I know that a lot of Philip Pullman fans were looking forward to this release, and many people felt that The Golden Compass would rival The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe in terms of broad appeal and popularity. But domestic audiences didn’t exactly flock to The Golden Compass, and I think part of the problem might have been the incomprehensibility of the story to someone unfamiliar with Pullman’s work.
Plot summary (with possible spoilers): The entire story takes place in a parallel universe where humans’ souls exist externally in the form of animals. The main character is Lyra Belacqua (played by Dakota Blue Richards) is a young orphan being raised by her uncle Lord Asriel (Daniel Craig) at Jordan College in Oxford. Lord Asriel is a controversial figure because of his beliefs about dust, a kind of dark matter that the ruling Magesterium denies even exists. After narrowly escaping an assassination attempt, Lord Asriel takes off on an expedition to the North in order to study dust more closely, thereby exiting for the rest of the film.
Meanwhile, Mrs. Coulter (Nicole Kidman), a benefactor of the college, comes for a visit and instantly takes a liking to Lyra. In fact, she says that Lyra would be perfect as her assistant, so she offers to take Lyra away with her. Lyra willingly agrees, but before she goes, the master of the college gives her a magical Golden Compass that can answer any question asked of it — as long as the questioner knows how to decipher the answer.
While Lyra is living with Mrs. Coulter, she learns that the woman is actually the head of an organization called the General Oblation Board, or “Gobblers” for short. The Gobblers are suspected of having kidnapped a number of Oxford children in order to experiment on them, so Lyra realizes that she’s in imminent danger. She therefore runs away from Mrs. Coulter, and joins forces with an aeronaut named Lee Scoresby (Sam Elliott) and a polar bear warrior named Iorek Byrnison (Ian McKellen) in order to find and rescue the endangered children.
The rest of the film then deals with Lyra, Lee, and Iorek’s adventures as they set off to find the missing kids. They get into a number of dangerous situations, fight an epic battle, and eventually emerge victorious as they save the children from harm.
My Reaction: As I said, I’ve never read the Pullman book, so I didn’t come into this viewing with an additional background information on the characters or the story in general. Because of this, I had a hard time understanding the significance of everything that happened in the film. For instance, I didn’t understand the whole point of having the action take place in a parallel universe. Was that just so there could be talking animal characters as well as humans? And what was the purpose of the Golden Compass? Did it actually tell Lyra any great truths that she couldn’t have otherwise figured out for herself?
Admittedly, I wasn’t paying as much attention as I could/should have while watching this film, so I might have missed the answers to these questions. Even so, the fact that I wasn’t compelled to pay attention means the story was less than interesting to me, which points to other shortcomings as well.
I was disappointed that Daniel Craig had such as small role in this film. I think his total screentime was probably about 5-10 minutes, which sucked. I like the actor, and would have preferred to see more of him than, say, Nicole Kidman or Dakota Blue Richards, who were both extremely grating and annoying after a while.
Overall, I just couldn’t get into The Golden Compass enough to bother trying to figure out what was going on. The story was boring and the entire effort just seemed a bit… lackluster. I give this movie just 2 stars out of 5.
I Am Legend was one of the biggest box office hits of 2007, finishing in sixth place on the year with an estimated domestic gross of $256,393,000 and change. The film received lots of positive reviews, and since I usually like Will Smith movies, I knew I’d eventually get around to seeing it. I didn’t have a chance to catch it in theaters, but was finally able to rent it last weekend.
I hardly ever watch anime because it always seems like there’s so much to keep up with. From an outsider’s perspective, it seems that nearly all of the top anime productions are based on entire series that would take hours and hours to try to catch up on. I simply don’t have that kind of time, so as a result, I usually don’t even bother with the genre.
I’m not really a big Nicole Kidman fan, despite the fact that I think she’s a terrific actress. The problem I have with Kidman is that she’s usually in films that I simply cannot stand. Cold Mountain, Moulin Rouge!, Eyes Wide Shut, The Interpreter… these were all incredibly boring movies to me. In fact, the only Kidman film that I’ve actually enjoyed is The Others, which came out way back in 2001.
When the titular hero of the 2001 Richard Kelly film Donnie Darko introduces himself to the new girl at the school, the first thing she says is, “Donnie Darko? What the hell kind of name is that? It’s like some kind of superhero or something.”
I’m not much of a comic book fan, so I was a bit worried about how my lack of superhero knowledge would affect my ability to enjoy a complimentary copy of the new Justice League: The New Frontier DVD that I received. From the trailers, I gathered that this film sought to explain how the legendary Justice League crime-fighting team was formed back in the 1950s.
I saw The Princess Bride with my family when it first came out 20 years ago. I remember liking it at the time, but I never got on board with the cult following, so I only saw the film from beginning to end just that once. Of course, I caught snippets on cable about 100 times in the years after that, so I still remembered pretty much the entire story when I sat down to watch my 20th Anniversary Collector’s Edition DVD the other day.
Although I’m a fan of the Harry Potter book series, I’m not one of those hard-core types who knows and remembers every single detail about every single character. But I do remember general storylines and the overall Harry vs. Voldemort arc, which is sufficient to get me from one book to the next.
I watched The Butterfly Effect last night, and I have to say that I was pretty impressed with the movie as a whole. I didn’t know anything about the movie prior to watching it except that Ashton Kutcher was in it. I had never seen him play a dramatic role, so I was looking forward to the change. I wasn’t disappointed!